Established in the early 1900s, the Beth Din of East Flatbush emerged as a central institution in Brooklyn's vibrant Jewish community. This period saw the neighborhood flourish with Jewish life, including numerous synagogues, yeshivas, and communal organizations. The Beth Din played a pivotal role in upholding Jewish law and guiding the community through its spiritual and legal needs.

Among the notable rabbis who served in East Flatbush were Rabbi Jacob J. Hecht, who led Congregation Yeshiva Rabbi Meir Simcha Hakohen at 309 E. 53rd St., and Rabbi Chaim Meir Bukiet, who oversaw Oneg Shabbos on E. 51st St. These leaders were instrumental in sustaining Jewish life during challenging times. Rabbi Michoel Teitelbaum's tireless efforts ensured the continuity of several shuls, even when the community began to dwindle. His dedication to maintaining daily minyanim and preserving Jewish institutions is legendary.

The Beth Din's legacy is a testament to the resilience and commitment of East Flatbush's Jewish community. Through the guidance of its esteemed rabbis, the Beth Din not only provided religious services but also fostered a sense of unity and continuity for generations. Today, the community continues to honor this rich heritage, ensuring that the traditions and values upheld by the Beth Din remain a cornerstone of Jewish life in East Flatbush.